Enterprise Technology By Phil Edholm

Being Green - Easy or Hard??

Well, I think Kermit (the Frog) was wrong.......it is easy bein' green.....for Nortel customers anyway. And especially when bein' green comes with great financial dividends as well.

The last couple of months have seen a swirling of points and counterpoints about what it means to be green in networking... it all started with some strong points by Nortel back at InterOp that the Nortel data products were much more energy efficient than some key competitors. While I have been looking at other areas, the information keeps piling up that Nortel is really a much better solution than Cisco.

In fact, a NEW TOLLY REPORT of a complete converged network including VoIP under different loads shows Nortel uses 40% less energy than Cisco. The Energy Efficiency extends from the data infrastructure into the telephony equipment, where Nortel phones use 40% less energy that equivalent Cisco devices. This continues the debate from before, but now includes more information and results. Also there are some interesting Energy Efficiency videso on YouTube at www.youtube.com/nortelvids.

Finally, the energy calculator I promised has been up for a while. In fact In-Stat says it is the only tool of it's kind in the industry. You can find it either by going to the Nortel SaveEnergy page or directly to the Nortel Energy Efficiency Calculator.

So, in the end it really is easier to be green. Sorry Kermit, but you were just ahead of your time....by the way, if you want to read the original lyrics, they can be found HERE, or a video of Kermit on YouTube.....in the end he agrees, being green is better, even if it is hard at the beginning. We couldn't agree more, engineering for green takes some time, but it is worth the reward.

Comments

  1. Phil,
    If choosing between a Ferarri and a Lambo to buy, who does it based on gas milage? Cup holders? Ease of conversion to burning French Fry oil?

    How much money is saved on energy by going Nortel compared to the purchase price of the product? If the energy savings exceeds the cost of the maintenance contract, getting “free maintenance” would be even more appealing than a free hemp T-shirt!

    Tolly Labs must be commended on their thriftyness in using an $18, uncalibrated, Kill-A-Watt power meter for the 115v measurements. I spotted that because our budget for test tools is similar.

  2. Phil,

    This question may be outside your domain, but I’ll ask anyway; is the AGW/MME being tested on the ATCA platform “green”? How does it compare to access gateways from other companies? How does it compare to (for example) the GGSN/SGSN/PDSN and RNC it replaces?

    As well, since most of the RNC function moved to the eNodeB; how does your partnerships with eNodeB vendors?

    Is this sort of measurement being conducted as a part of the LSTI?

    http://www2.nortel.com/go/news_detail.jsp?cat_id=-8055&oid=100238613

    ….and why does nortel make product announcements on April Fools Day? :)

  3. Sorry, didn’t complete my thought…it sould read:

    As well, since most of the RNC function moved to the eNodeB; how does your partnerships with eNodeB vendors fair in “green networking” ?

  4. You are right - it is outside my domain, though I will endeavor to get an answer.

  5. Nortel is energy and green conscious. The BTS portfolio has and will continue to evolve year over year generation over generation. For example in one line of wireless technology, the energy consumption has decreased by well over 70%, weighs over 85% less and takes over 85% less space.

  6. And the savings continue……

Leave a Reply